Step forward: On the Shishupal judgment
Practice PYQs on this topic
500+ questions on Polity with explanations
๐ Summary:
-
A Supreme Court Division Bench (Justices Sanjay Karol & N.K. Singh) in Shishupal @Shish Ram vs Surjeet revised motor-accident compensation for a 2001 road-accident victim (Reshma) from โน8.43 lakh (Punjab & Haryana HC, 2024) to โน62.78 lakh
-
The Court attached โน30,000/month "economic value" to the deceased homemaker's unpaid domestic service
-
Legal reasoning: a homemaker's work cannot be discounted merely because it is unpaid or performed by women; the โน30,000 floor is notional, to be hiked 10% every three years, with a woman's salary (where applicable) added on top
-
Precedents: Lata Wadhwa (2001) valued homemaker services at a modest โน3,000; Kirti vs Oriental Insurance (2021) held unpaid work has economic value โ but quantification remained inconsistent
-
Limits: ruling applies only to MACT compensation; it creates no salary, pension or employment relationship for homemakers
-
Ripple effects: connects to the suppressed female labour-force participation debate; aids homemakers' maintenance claims under the Hindu Marriage Act; rural women's farm labour (sowing, harvesting, cattle-tending) can be valued higher; future litigation may test male homemakers' claims; insurers may revise risk models as average claim sizes rise (likely applied retrospectively)
๐ฏ UPSC Relevance: GS1 โ Indian Society / role of women and the valuation of women's unpaid work; intersects with GS2 (judiciary) and labour economics.
๐ Prelims Facts:
-
Case: Shishupal @Shish Ram vs Surjeet (2026); Bench: Justices Sanjay Karol and N.K. Singh
-
Compensation revised to โน62.78 lakh; homemaker value โน30,000/month, +10% every 3 years
-
Precedents: Lata Wadhwa (2001), Kirti vs Oriental Insurance (2021); body: Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT)
๐ Key Term: Notional income โ an imputed monetary value assigned to non-monetised work (e.g., a homemaker's labour) for computing legal compensation.
UPSC Classification
See PYQs related to โPolityโ
Every classification tag above links to actual UPSC questions asked on that topic โ with answer, explanation and elimination logic. Only in the app.